In the vast expanse of the English Channel, the supertanker Torrey Canyon met its fate in 1967, not due to a sudden storm or mechanical failure, but because of a human tendency that aviation psychologists would later term "plan continuation bias." This cognitive trap, where individuals stick to their original plan despite changing circumstances, isn't limited to maritime or aviation disasters. It permeates our daily lives and, crucially, our business decisions, especially when it comes to innovation.
Understanding Plan Continuation Bias in Business
CustomersPlan continuation bias, a concept originating from aviation safety studies, refers to the tendency to persist with an original course of action, even when changing circumstances suggest the plan is no longer appropriate or safe. While this phenomenon is most extensively studied and discussed in aviation, its principles have valuable applications in the business world.
In a business context, plan continuation bias manifests as resistance to changing strategies or adopting innovations, even when market conditions, technological advancements, or consumer preferences indicate the need for a new direction. It's the corporate equivalent of a pilot flying into a storm because that was the original flight plan, despite clear weather warnings.
This bias can be particularly dangerous in today's rapidly evolving business landscape. Companies that fall victim to this tendency may find themselves clinging to outdated business models, ignoring disruptive technologies, or failing to adapt to changing consumer behaviors. The result? They risk becoming modern-day Torrey Canyons, running aground on the rocks of obsolescence.
Consider Kodak, once a titan of the photography industry. Despite inventing the first digital camera in 1975, the company clung to its film-based business model, unable to pivot towards the digital future it had ironically helped create. By the time Kodak finally embraced digital photography, it was too late. The company filed for bankruptcy in 2012, a victim of its success and inability to change course.
In the following sections, we'll explore why businesses often struggle to change direction, the costs of this inflexibility, and strategies for overcoming plan continuation bias to foster innovation and adaptability in a changing business environment.
The Fear that Anchors Us
Why do businesses, like ships on a collision course with disaster, find it difficult to change direction? The fear of innovation often stems from a complex mix of factors:
Sunk Cost Fallacy - Companies invest heavily in existing systems and processes, making it psychologically difficult to abandon them.
Risk Aversion - The unknown risks of new technologies or methods can seem more daunting than the familiar risks of current practices.
Organizational Inertia - Large organizations, in particular, can be slow to change due to complex hierarchies and established procedures.
Short-Term Thinking - The immediate costs and disruptions of innovation can overshadow long-term benefits.
These factors combine to create a powerful bias toward maintaining the status quo, even when change is desperately needed.
The High Price of Stagnation
The cost of resisting innovation can be catastrophic. Blockbuster's refusal to adapt to the streaming model pioneered by Netflix led to its downfall. Nokia's reluctance to embrace the smartphone revolution saw it lose its dominant position in the mobile phone market. These cautionary tales highlight the dangers of plan continuation bias in the face of disruptive innovation.
Charting a New Course
Overcoming plan continuation bias requires a deliberate effort to challenge our assumptions and remain open to new ideas. Here are some strategies businesses can employ:
Regular Strategy Reviews: Set up periodic assessments of your business strategy, actively looking for signs that it may need adjustment.
Encourage Dissent: Create a culture where challenging the status quo is not just accepted but encouraged.
Scenario Planning: Regularly engage in exercises that imagine different future scenarios, including disruptive changes in your industry.
Embrace Small-Scale Experiments: Test new ideas on a small scale to reduce risk and gather data before making large-scale changes.
Foster a Learning Culture: Encourage continuous learning and skill development among employees to keep the organization adaptable.
Balancing Innovation and Consistency: Lessons from Success Stories
Navigating the complexities of innovation requires a delicate balancing act between maintaining a steady course and being open to change. Businesses must recognize that while consistency in vision and values is crucial, adaptability is equally important in today’s rapidly evolving landscape.
Successful companies demonstrate how this balance can be achieved. For instance, Amazon has maintained its core focus on customer service while continuously innovating in areas like cloud computing and artificial intelligence. This commitment to both consistency and innovation has allowed Amazon to remain a leader in multiple industries.
Similarly, IBM's transformation from a hardware-centric company to a leader in cloud computing and services illustrates the power of embracing change while staying true to its foundational principles. By pivoting strategically and investing in new technologies, IBM has managed to redefine its identity without losing sight of its core mission.
Netflix provides another compelling example. Initially a DVD rental service, it successfully transitioned into a streaming giant and content creator by embracing change rather than resisting it. This adaptability has not only kept Netflix relevant but has also positioned it as an industry innovator.
To effectively navigate this balance, organizations can focus on fostering a culture that encourages experimentation and learning. This involves creating an environment where team members feel empowered to propose new ideas and challenge existing processes. Regularly engaging in discussions about market trends and emerging technologies can also help teams remain agile and informed.
Additionally, organizations should prioritize open communication channels that allow for feedback on both ongoing projects and long-term strategies. By actively listening to insights from various levels within the company, leaders can better gauge when it’s time to pivot or double down on existing plans.
Ultimately, the most successful organizations are those that can maintain their core values while remaining agile enough to adapt when necessary. By learning from the experiences of industry leaders, businesses can overcome plan continuation bias and thrive in an environment that demands constant evolution.
_________________________________
We are MPL Innovation, a boutique innovation consultancy.
Our mission is to empower our clients by propelling their corporate innovation initiatives to new heights.
With our specialized innovation consulting services, we assist organizations in surpassing their boundaries and unlocking unprecedented growth opportunities.
Follow us ➡️ HERE